Why I Don’t Like Developers
By Some Guy
Many years ago, somewhere around the end of 1959, the Arvida Corporation, a rapacious mega-developer with Arthur Vining Davis at the helm, showboated into Sarasota, Florida, and announced the plans to develop the old John Ringling properties into a mega-monstrosity of mammoth proportions. The developments involved dredging tens of thousands of cubic feet of extraordinary tidal and estuary land and piling it up to build an empire of fancy homes build on loose sand. A.B. Edwards, a real-estate developer living in Sarasota, was aghast. He stated, “When you interfere with the channels, bars, currents, and waterways, you’re liable to have trouble.” The man was prescient, long before researchers established the crucial role these areas played in fish breeding habitat and water quality.
First, they pillaged Bird Key by digging up the tidal flats around the little spit of land, piling up the sand, and crowding 511 houses onto the resulting sandpile. The Arvida corporation, whetting the avaricious instincts of otherwise-decent, local real estate agents, offered luxury yachts and automobiles as incentives to whom could sell the most lots on the key.

Bird Key, before Arvida

Bird Key, after Arvida. The Arvida corporation dredged up and filled in the entire tidal flat visible in the other photo.
Neighboring Otter Key is a small island surrounded by tidal flats and tangled in mangrove and Australian Pine. Although seemingly inconsequential at the time, it provided habitat for manatees and dolphins, and is an important nesting and breeding ground for many different species. It was also right out our back door. It was a constant backdrop to our daily lives. As my brother and I played in the yard, the key was there. Fishing was incredible, and perching in the mangroves for an entire afternoon with a fishing pole was an ideal way to spend a Saturday afternoon. As the seasons progressed, different colonies of birds would flock into the mangrove, from herons to pelicans to ibis and spoonbills. The tidal flat right in front of our house harbored millions of hatchling fish and crabs. We could hear the wind whispering through the Australian Pines across the bayou. As a kid, I knew every mangrove tunnel that lead to the shell-strewn spit of land inside the mangroves. I knew every square foot of the island, and I’d spend weekends searching the island for evidence that the apocryphal pirate Gasparilla had once hidden away on the island.

Otter Key Today
After the demise of Bird Key and its zombie-like rise from the tidal flats of Sarasota Bay, Arvida turned it piggy, greedy eyes onto Otter Key in 1967. They planned to develop the island, along with the entire south end of Lido Key, into a mega-resort, complete with huge golf course, parks, waterfront resort hotels, and high-rise apartment buildings. By this point, a sense of alarm and outrage was spreading around the residents of the keys. It became evident that the Arvida Corporation was planning to dredge and fill in most of Sarasota Bay from the causeway to Big Pass, effectively destroying the entire bay. Before environmentalism was socially fashionable, John Bergen, my grandparents, and twenty-nine other concerned citizens formed the first “Save Our Bay” association (my grandfather’s humorous idea of a group name), affectionately or derisively referred to as the S.O.B.s, with the stated goal of preserving the bay from the ravages of unchecked and reckless development. The Arvida corporation was ruthless in assaulting the nascent environmental group at every turn, prowling the city halls and commisions in the county lobbying for injunctions and lavishing favors upon the politicians. Due to the long history and social standing of many of the citizens in the S.O.B.s, the mayor of Sarasota, Jack Betz, overrode the strenuous legal objections of the Arvida corporation and allowed the S.0.B.s to file petitions with hundreds of signatures from local residents.

Otter Key/South Lido project envisioned by Arvida
During the legal battles, I recall when the Arvida corporation sent unctious spokesmen around to my grandparents’ house where they dripped charm across the living room floor. “But we’re so eager to be your neighbors,” he oozed. “Just imagine how wonderful it will be to wave across the canal to your neighbors while you’re eating breakfast!” While growling vile curses and promises of legal vengeance, my grandfather ushered them unceremoniously from the house.
The S.O.B.s bought full-page spreads in the local and regional newspapers. They packed city council meetings. They petitioned city and county commissioners. They attracted the attention of the local television media. They even had bright orange bumper stickers before anyone knew what they were. In the end, the S.O.B.s prevailed. The Arvida Corporation’s grandiose plans were vanquished, and from that point on, Arvida had to deal with the S.O.B.s at every turn, who had then become watchdogs to hold uncontrolled development in check. Members of S.O.B. became politically active, and were elected into office. They successfully passed a bond issue that purchased Otter Key, Casperson Beach, South Lido Key, and land in North Lido Key for 7.5 million dollars. Otter Key and the surrounding tidal flats became a protected wildlife habitat, which by now we know helped protect the increasingly-troubled, local fishing industry by providing fish breeding habitat.
Save Our Bays groups began springing up across western Florida to battle the ravages of unchecked development, much to the irritation of the money-blinded developers that wanted to destroy the landscape of coastal Florida.
Arvida Corporation was gobbled up by the Disney conglomerate. Don’t ask me how I feel about that.
Addendum: (11/14): Sarasota Magazine has a good piece by Craig Pittman on the depressing environmental history of Sarasota Bay. My fave quote from the article:
“I see a lot of houses where I never see any people outside,” the fishing guide says. “People pay an exorbitant price for that view and never enjoy it. They never look outside. They don’t care if it has any fish in it. Maybe if it stunk real bad, then they’d care about it.”
Thanks to hermetically-sealed houses and A/C, I don’t think they’d care even if we dumped dead fish from a red tide kill into their back yard.
Tags: development, environment, florida, Politics